Feb 20, 2024 at 3:17 AM#11
Six months is the sweet spot for repeat FibroScan. At 3 months, changes in liver stiffness may not be reliably detectable above the test's measurement variability (~1.5 kPa). Doing it too early can create false reassurance or unnecessary alarm.
As for tirzepatide vs. semaglutide for MASH:
The honest answer is we don't have head-to-head biopsy data yet. What we know:
Semaglutide: More published MASH-specific data. The Phase 2 trial showed ~59% MASH resolution at 0.4mg (higher than the 2.4mg standard dose). ESSENCE Phase 3 data is the most anticipated dataset.
Tirzepatide: The SYNERGY-NASH Phase 2 showed MASH resolution rates of ~74% at the 15mg dose, with fibrosis improvement in ~47%. The GIP component may offer additional anti-inflammatory effects in the liver beyond what GLP-1 alone provides.
Based on the Phase 2 data, tirzepatide appears to have a modest edge, but these are different trials with different populations, so direct comparison is unreliable.
Bottom line: both are excellent choices. Your response at 3 months suggests tirzepatide is working well for you. Don't second-guess the choice — focus on adherence, lifestyle, and monitoring.
Last edited: Feb 20, 2024 at 8:17 AM
41 3sarah_nash92, FitDadDave, RunnerRach and 38 others
Reply Quote Save Share Report